Pepkor Directors and Investors Raise Alarm Over CEO's Stake in $1.3bn Flash-Shop2Shop Fintech Merger
Pepkor Directors and Investors Raise Alarm Over CEO’s Stake in $1.3bn Flash-Shop2Shop Fintech Merger #
South African retail giant Pepkor is under pressure from some of its own board members and institutional shareholders over a deal struck in July to merge its fintech unit, Flash, with payments rival Shop2Shop. The transaction created a combined entity provisionally called FintechCo, valued at approximately R21.3 billion ($1.3 billion).
According to Moneyweb, citing a person familiar with the matter who declined to be named because the board vote is not public, a number of Pepkor directors voted against the transaction. Their objection centred on the absence of a formal shareholder vote on what critics argue amounts to a significant strategic departure for Africa’s largest clothing retailer.
Pepkor CEO Pieter Erasmus holds an indirect minority stake of 13.2% in the newly formed FintechCo, derived from a pre-existing 31.2% interest in Shop2Shop that predates his appointment at Pepkor and was disclosed in the group’s annual financial statements. That stake is now estimated to be worth around R2.8 billion, or roughly $169 million. Erasmus recused himself from board deliberations on the transaction.
Aeon Investment Management, identified as a top-30 shareholder in Pepkor, has publicly argued that shareholders should have been given the right to vote on a deal in which the CEO stands to benefit so substantially. Pepkor structured the transaction as a Category 2 deal under Johannesburg Stock Exchange listing rules. Because Erasmus’s interest falls below the 35% associate threshold that would trigger a related-party classification, no shareholder vote was legally required.
Pepkor acquired its 57.1% controlling stake in FintechCo by injecting R1.57 billion in cash into Shop2Shop to retire its debt, while simultaneously contributing 100% of Flash, valued at R10.6 billion, in exchange for new shares in the combined group. Shop2Shop shareholders retained the remaining 42.9% stake. The merged platform, which serves both formal and informal sectors of South Africa’s economy, will process more than R200 billion in transactions annually.
Pepkor’s independent directors concluded that the transaction was fair and reasonable, a position supported by a voluntary independent fairness opinion. The company has indicated it intends to separately list FintechCo on the JSE in the medium term.
Critics, including dissenting board members and Aeon, have focused on the deal’s structure: it was classified in a category that required no shareholder vote despite the CEO’s personal financial interest in the counterparty.
Copy link